The Mess in the Middle East

I find myself in the weird position of having both sympathy and condemnation for the Palestinians in Gaza. I don’t know whether to criticize the Israelis for all the civilian casualties or to criticize the Palestinian civilians for bringing it on themselves.

As to my sympathy for the Palestinians, it’s simple. I believe that the Balfour Declaration and subsequent British mandates are travesties of British colonialism. The Palestinians were robbed of lands that had been theirs for 1300 years. I don’t think most Americans know this.

There is some sense in American politics that the Israelis and the Palestinians both have equal claims to the land and that both have been locked in a struggle for it for hundreds of years. I don’t think that most Americans realize that the last Jewish “state” was the Kingdom of Judea in 600 AD. Between then and 1948, with the exception of a hundred years or so of Crusader-rule, the land of modern Israel had been under Muslim rule of one flavor or another. Whether being “under Muslim rule” constitutes a formal Palestinian state or not, I think, is irrelevant. What’s clear is that there was no formal Jewish state in the area for 1300 years. It can be argued that the land should belong to the Egyptians or to Turkey or to Arabic tribesmen, but going back to 600 AD to establish provenance seems like a stretch.

Israel’s claim to their land is based on the religious argument of Zionism – that God had granted them these “Promised Lands.” Historians suggest that the British drafted the Balfour declaration in order to secure Jewish support to finance the war against Germany in WWI (the Ottoman Turks, who ruled Palestine, had sided with Germany). Without getting too much into personal religious beliefs, let me say that, at the very least, accepting Zionism as an argument for carving out a Jewish state from the lands of Palestine is, at best, biased towards Judeo-Christian dogma. The Muslims/Palestinians have their religious claim to the same lands that the British chose to overlook when proposing the partitioning of Palestine/Transjordan. Should the Scientologists lay claim to West Hollywood or the Zoroastrians to Kashmir, I doubt the UN would pay much attention to either.

I emphasize “partitioning” because it was not the British intent to completely disenfranchise the Palestinians; they intended there to be both Jewish and Palestinian states as per their mandates.

Given this, it seems eminently reasonable that there be some pissed off Palestinians.

On the other hand, regardless of whether the Palestinians are justified in their anger, the fact remains that Israel is there and it’s unreasonable to expect that it go away. The fact also remains that lobbying missiles and rockets at random civilian targets is the action of terrorist thugs and not that of indignant freedom fighters.

Regardless of what maneuverings might have led to the creation of the Jewish state, the state exists. The founding of Israel was accomplished through quasi-legitimate means (the League of Nations and UN were involved somewhere along the way) and Israelis have a valid claim that they followed the necessary protocols. We are not going to give Manhattan back to the Native Americans and the Israelis are not going to walk away from Jerusalem and Tel Aviv.

So, taking into account the righteousness of their anger, we need to consider what is the appropriate Palestinian response.

I can accept the Arab rejection of partioning in 1948. At that point, they had some reasonable hope that Israel be later defeated and driven out. By 1967, however, it should have been clear that the elimination of Israel was not a likely option. I’m convinced that the Palestinians would have been much better off if they’d accepted the proposals resulting from the Oslo accords in the 90’s during the Clinton administration. I think it was Arafat who admitted that the Palestinians are “Never ones to miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity.”

Hamas’ failure to recognize Israel and its pledge to keep working towards its destruction are understandable and “fundamental” (as in “Fundamentalism”). The group refuses to accept the injustice of 1948 and all the history that followed. Understandable or not, however, it is unrealistic, nihilistic and bad for the Palestinian people. Would the majority of Palestinians fight to the death rather than accepting the partitioning of Palestinian land? Hamas would have this be so, but they’re wrong. Most Palestinians are ready for a negotiated peace even if it means accepting the injust confiscation of Palestinian land.

And yet, in 2006, Hamas won a majority of seats in the Palestinian Parliamentary elections.

The accepted explanation for this is that the populace was sick of the corruption of the Palestinian Authority/Fatah and voted for Hamas in spite of their more militant stance against Israel. Regardless, Hamas did not hide its political stance nor mislead the Palestinian voters. At best, they voted for Hamas in the hope that it would be less corrupt while also hoping that they wouldn’t cause too much trouble with Israel.  At worst, they voted for Hamas because they were more militant.

How could Israel be expected to handle an overt enemy within its borders? Clearly, they could expect that Iran would supply weapons to Hamas through its porous Egyptian border. Israel could not stand by idly letting this happen and, as such, moved to secure the Gaza borders. They sought, too, to destabilize Hamas by laying a virtual siege on Gaza. Hamas responded by sending rockets into Israel. At the conclusion of the ceasefire agreement last year, with no end in sight to border restrictions, Hamas significantly increased rocket fire into Israel, prompting the latest assault.

I believe that Hamas is posturing when it blames the rocket attacks on Israeli border restrictions and on political assasinations. I would expect that, even if without these provocations, Hamas would be lobbing rockets and missiles into Israel. They would cite a different motive, perhaps, but would attack nonetheless. The group is open regarding its hostile position regarding Israel. It is only being true to its rhetoric when it fires rockets and missiles.

Ultimately, the residents of Gaza need to understand that they are complicit in establishing the situation that led to the Israeli military operations. They cannot elect leaders overtly hostile to Israel and expect Israel to not defend itself against these leaders. I hate to see children and other civilians dying in any war but they Palestinians should accept their own roles in these deaths.

Beyond the basis for their state, there is plenty of blame to be meted to Israel, too. The lack of political will to stop settlement activity is unacceptable. Israelis must understand that the concept of “Greater Israel” is no more realistic than the Palestinian notions of driving the Israelis into the sea. So, too, must Israelis accept that, at best, Jerusalem will be a divided city. So, too, must Israelis stop the unscrupulous taking of Palestinian lands through illegal or merely “unethical” means.

Both sides must understand that, at best, they will achieve a tenous peace that will last long enough for all the current hotheads to die off and leave the pragmatists behind.

152 Responses to “The Mess in the Middle East”

  1. some genuinely interesting info , well written and broadly speaking user pleasant.

  2. I keep listening to the news lecture about getting boundless online grant applications so I have been looking around for the best site to get one. Could you tell me please, where could i acquire some?

  3. I gotta favorite this internet site it seems very beneficial invaluable

  4. StephenPaply says:

    no prescription viagra viagra without a doctor prescription viagra without a doctor prescription canada

  5. Jamesdaymn says:

    how much viagra should i take the first time? buy viagra buy viagra online cheap

  6. DanielEmind says:

    viagra cost cheap viagra over the counter viagra cvs

  7. WallyLes says:

    canadian online drugs causes of ed ed cures

  8. WallyLes says:

    injectable ed drugs how to fix ed buy prescription drugs without doctor

  9. Stevenslilk says:

    viagra cialis cheap ed pills price of viagra

  10. Stevenslilk says:

    viagra amazon cheap viagra viagra no prescription

  11. Stevenslilk says:

    mail order viagra viagra viagra without a prescription

  12. Stevenslilk says:

    mail order viagra cheap viagra viagra prices

  13. DanielEnank says:

    men ed Cheap Erection Pills ed medications

  14. DanielEnank says:

    ed help cheap ed pills erectyle dysfunction

  15. DanielEnank says:

    buy ed drugs Cheap Erection Pills mens erection pills

  16. DanielEnank says:

    pharmacy drugs cheap ed pills ed clinic

  17. DanielEnank says:

    how to get prescription drugs without doctor Cheap Erection Pills erection pills online

  18. NathanHok says:

    cialis vs levitra cialis online cialis vidalista

  19. AndrewNiz says:

    coupon for cialis by manufacturer cialis online 30ml liquid cialis
    interactions for cialis

  20. NathanHok says:

    cialis erection penis cialis samples of cialis

  21. Williamphish says:

    ed medications comparison drug prices comparison over the counter ed remedies

  22. Williamphish says:

    drug prices comparison drug prices comparison ed trial pack

  23. RobertKic says:

    payday loans online payday loans no credit check instant approval

  24. RobertKic says:

    tadalafil tadalafil online

  25. RobertKic says:

    cheapest sildenafil sildenafil without doctor prescription

  26. RobertKic says:

    canadian pharmacy drugs from india

  27. RobertKic says:

    india pharmacy buy generic drugs online

  28. Heya i’m for the first time here. I found this board and I in finding It truly helpful &
    it helped me out much. I hope to give one thing again and help others like you aided me.

  29. RobertPrina says:

    buy sildenafil online sildenafil generic

  30. JoshuaAsype says:

    sildenafil sildenafil online

  31. StephenFed says:

    viagra over the counter usa 2020 cheap viagra how to get viagra without a doctor

  32. CaseyHof says:

    ed meds online without doctor prescription viagra canada

  33. RobinAmara says:

    cialis for peyronie cialis online cialis price

  34. RobinAmara says:

    male erection pills buy Amoxil ed supplements

  35. RobinAmara says:

    best ed treatment online canadian pharmacy reasons for ed

  36. RodneyAffog says:

    online doctor prescription for viagra buy viagra goodrx viagra

  37. RobinAmara says:

    online drugstore buy Amoxil best drug for ed

  38. RodneyAffog says:

    ed pills online pharmacy online pharmacy canada ed remedies

  39. RobinAmara says:

    ed devices canadian drug stores ed treatment

  40. RobinAmara says:

    best male ed pills buy Cipro online online ed drugs

  41. RodneyAffog says:

    cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis taking l-citrulline and cialis together

  42. RobinAmara says:

    canadian online pharmacy online canadian pharmacy medicine for ed

  43. RodneyAffog says:

    ed meds online without doctor prescription buy Doxycyline erectile dysfunction pills

  44. RobinAmara says:

    ed online pharmacy generic Zithromax how to get prescription drugs without doctor

  45. RodneyAffog says:

    buying pills online online canadian pharmacy online prescription for ed meds

  46. RobinAmara says:

    foods for ed canadian pharmacy review buy prescription drugs online legally

  47. RodneyAffog says:

    viagra amazon viagra viagra amazon

  48. RobinAmara says:

    viagra without a doctor prescription buy Cipro online buy anti biotics without prescription

  49. RodneyAffog says:

    drugs that cause ed canada drugs online errection problems

  50. TravisLes says:

    prescription meds without the prescriptions: can ed be reversed top erection pills

  51. EdwardPed says:

    prescription drugs: prescription without a doctor’s prescription best drugs for erectile dysfunction

  52. TravisLes says:

    canadian online drugs: ed drugs list natural pills for ed

  53. EdwardPed says:

    online drugstore: canadian drug prices new erectile dysfunction treatment

  54. Larryorelt says:

    can you have multiple orgasms with cialis where to get cialis sample cialis cost

  55. RichardHot says:

    buy viagra cost of viagra cheapest viagra online

  56. Larryorelt says:

    viagra without a doctor prescription usa canadian viagra viagra prices

  57. Larryorelt says:

    cheap drugs canadian pharmacies shipping to usa anti fungal pills without prescription

  58. RichardHot says:

    zithromax online usa zithromax capsules 250mg zithromax 1000 mg online

  59. Larryorelt says:

    generic zithromax online paypal generic zithromax azithromycin can you buy zithromax over the counter in australia

  60. RichardHot says:

    buy ed pills online online pharmacies in canada the canadian drugstore

  61. Larryorelt says:

    online drugs online pharmacies in canada ed natural treatment

  62. RichardHot says:

    zithromax prescription cheap zithromax pills generic zithromax india

  63. Larryorelt says:

    generic names for cialis and viagra cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis samples request

  64. RichardHot says:

    cheap medication canadian pharmacy cialis top rated ed pills

  65. RichardHot says:

    zithromax 500 zithromax over the counter uk cheap zithromax pills

  66. Robertunlow says:

    otc viagra buy viagra online over the counter viagra cvs
    viagra pill

  67. Robertunlow says:

    viagra online canadian pharmacy buy viagra online viagra prescription
    mail order viagra

  68. ThomasGab says:

    cost of viagra viagra generic for sale viagra cost per pill
    viagra 100mg

  69. DavidTek says:

    Doxycycline antibiotics Flagyl antibiotics tadalafil without a doctor’s prescription

  70. Jamesbab says:

    natural help for ed cheap Valtrex generic Zovirax

  71. DavidTek says:

    Amoxil antibiotics buy Flagyl ed vacuum pump

  72. DavidTek says:

    online ed drugs best erectile dysfunction medication men’s ed pills

  73. Jamesbab says:

    erection pills pharmacies not requiring a prescription canadian pharmacies shipping usa

  74. DavidTek says:

    ed solutions canadian mail in pharmacy canadian pharmacy viagra

  75. Jamesbab says:

    google viagra dosage recommendations canadian licensed pharmacies listing certified canadian online pharmacies

  76. DavidTek says:

    prescription drugs without prior prescription cheap Aciclovir Valtrex

  77. DavidTek says:

    ed aids top erection pills buy erectile dysfunction medications online

  78. Jamesbab says:

    pet meds without vet prescription canadian pharmacies shipping usa canadian pharmacy cialis

  79. DavidTek says:

    diabetes and ed online pharmacies without an rx certified canadian online pharmacies

  80. Jamesbab says:

    buy Amoxil cenmox 250 doctors for erectile dysfunction

  81. avoitaPal says:

    Buy Doxycycline Paypal AbignKignene cialis without a doctor’s prescription foessEmeds Silvitra

  82. GregoryGrise says:

    pump for ed canada online pharmacy canadian pharmacy

  83. Josephmog says:

    buy viagra online canada 100mg viagra canadian pharmacy viagra

  84. GregoryGrise says:

    muse for ed ed remedies that really work erectyle dysfunction

  85. Josephmog says:

    amazon viagra how much viagra should i take the first time? cheapest viagra online

  86. Josephmog says:

    can ed be reversed ed treatments that really work prices of viagra at walmart

  87. GregoryGrise says:

    medication drugs ed trial pack generic ed pills

  88. Josephmog says:

    natural ed pills canada drug pharmacy canada drugs online

  89. GregoryGrise says:

    male enhancement pills buy lipitor online lipitor for sale

  90. Kennethcut says:

    nozezuqr viagra viagra cost

  91. Michaelronse says:

    generic name for viagra nikwycph

  92. Kennethcut says:

    buy viagra online canada ezoopsfa

  93. Michaelronse says:

    generic name for viagra rlgdpfvt

  94. hey says:

    Taxi moto line
    128 Rue la Boétie
    75008 Paris
    +33 6 51 612 712  

    Taxi moto paris

    Excellent blog here! Also your web site loads up very fast!
    What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to
    your host? I wish my site loaded up as fast as yours lol

  95. Warrenreesy says:

    yasmin nouri yasmin pill price shatavari for fertility

  96. Warrencag says:

    yasmin pill canada yasmin 28 canada buy clomid online

  97. Warrenreesy says:

    acyclovir 400 mg tablet buy valtrex online without a prescription order acyclovir online no prescription

  98. Warrencag says:

    alesse buy buy serophene alesse coupon

  99. Warrenreesy says:

    antibiotic coverage chart zithromax generic price order septra online

  100. Warrenreesy says:

    natural antibiotic best antibiotic for eye infection buy amoxicillin online mexico

  101. Warrencag says:

    best shatavari brand in india shatavari tablets price in india buy yasmin pill online uk

  102. Warrenreesy says:

    zyrtec 30 tablets brand name allegra allegra 30 mg pill

  103. Warrencag says:

    acyclovir cream 50mg buy valtrex without a prescription zovirax capsules 200mg

  104. Warrenreesy says:

    clomid generic name levlen generic for clomid

  105. Warrencag says:

    acyclovir online prescription famvir famciclovir acyclovir online purchase

  106. Warrenreesy says:

    prescription benadryl cream allegra canada otc 76 mg benadryl

  107. Warrencag says:

    doxycycline 100mg price buy zithromax without presc bactrim tablets

  108. Warrencag says:

    benadryl australia benadryl 15mg purchase zyrtec

  109. Edwardjet says:

    qllvtqap viagra for men online viagra

  110. Haroldwibia says:

    viagra over the counter usa 2020 cheap viagra pnqrzcxd

  111. Edwardjet says:

    cjomnxfr safe alternatives to viagra and cialis does cialis make you bigger

  112. Edwardjet says:

    adajwyyn buy viagra online usa walmart viagra

  113. Haroldwibia says:

    how much is viagra cost of viagra bgesthbj

  114. Haroldwibia says:

    cialis tolerance hard erections cialis lsgztrbw

  115. Edwardjet says:

    mqgduzbt cialis at a discount price cialis 30 day trial coupon

  116. Haroldwibia says:

    viagra online usa canadian pharmacy viagra hzllzmvf

  117. JasonCapse says:

    pump for ed best non prescription ed pills

  118. KennethHab says:

    real viagra without a doctor prescription usa canadian pharmacy online medications for ed

  119. JasonCapse says:

    erectile dysfunction ed causes and cures

  120. KennethHab says:

    best ed pills online canadian pharmacy viagra erectile dysfunction cure

  121. Antonia says:

    My brother recommended I would possibly like this web site.
    He used to be entirely right. This publish truly made my day.
    You cann’t believe just how much time I had spent for this information! Thank you!

  122. Jlloirore says:

    24 hr pharmacy ed pills online pharmacy cheap

  123. Teodoro says:

    You ought to take part in a contest for one of the
    greatest blogs on the net. I will highly recommend this site!

  124. I simply wanted to thank you very much once more. I do not know what I would have tried without these techniques shared by you regarding that subject matter. It was before an absolute scary scenario in my position, nevertheless taking note of this specialized tactic you solved the issue took me to weep with happiness. Now i’m thankful for your support and thus trust you really know what an amazing job you were putting in training the mediocre ones via your webpage. Most probably you haven’t met any of us.

  125. tofranil says:

    My husband and i felt now excited Emmanuel could conclude his inquiry from your ideas he gained in your site. It’s not at all simplistic just to choose to be giving for free ideas that most people have been making money from. And we all do understand we have the website owner to be grateful to because of that. The explanations you’ve made, the easy site menu, the friendships you can give support to engender – it’s everything extraordinary, and it’s facilitating our son and our family feel that that idea is cool, and that is highly important. Many thanks for all the pieces!

  126. venlor price says:

    A lot of thanks for all your valuable labor on this web site. My mother take interest in participating in research and it is simple to grasp why. My spouse and i notice all regarding the powerful way you produce useful thoughts via your website and in addition recommend response from the others on this subject then our own princess is undoubtedly studying a whole lot. Take pleasure in the rest of the year. You have been performing a terrific job.

  127. Jtmfapeno says:

    online canadian pharmacy ed pills that work quickly treatment for erectile dysfunction

  128. PhillipOdodo says:

    how to cure ed naturally
    generic ed pills

  129. Fwsxapeno says:

    online canadian pharmacy rx pharmacy coupons best erectile dysfunction pills

  130. Kennethpoore says:

    causes of ed
    viagra without a doctor prescription

  131. PhillipOdodo says:

    mexican pharmacy without prescription
    ed pharmacy

  132. Lokuapeno says:

    indian pharmacy discount pharmacy pharmacy prices

  133. Khthsmat says:

    dollar store drug test rx pharmacy tops pharmacy

  134. Kennethpoore says:

    over the counter ed
    real viagra without a doctor prescription

  135. NllpExork says:

    peoples pharmacy drug store near me discount pharmacy card

  136. JamesLap says:

    male erection pills twlqostn order levitra natural ed medications

  137. Rickyker says:

    discount viagra jwhtgpmk order viagra online

  138. JamesLap says:

    30ml liquid cialis cialis lbxvzmpf safe alternatives to viagra and cialis

  139. Rickyker says:

    which is better – cialis or viagra bmvsbfzx safe alternatives to viagra and cialis

  140. JamesLap says:

    vacuum pump for ed eagfyjjd levitra prescription drugs online without doctor

  141. Daryl says:

    Greetings from Los angeles! I’m bored to death at work so I decided to check out your
    website on my iphone during lunch break. I enjoy the knowledge you provide here and can’t
    wait to take a look when I get home. I’m surprised at how quick your blog loaded on my cell phone ..

    I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyhow, wonderful site!

  142. Rickyker says:

    online ed meds prescription drugs rgfplvkz

  143. Rickyker says:

    pain meds without written prescription how to get prescription drugs without doctor enerutfi

  144. JamesLap says:

    100mg viagra dkqrjkik buy cheap viagra viagra otc

  145. Rickyker says:

    how to cure ed naturally treatment with drugs hdnsquqz

  146. Rickyker says:

    prescription drugs online without best pills for ed vsxfloqn

  147. JamesCLADA says:

    tlbj over the counter viagra ltvu qaga

  148. SamuelFeesy says:

    ktqe mexican viagra heyy wkfy

  149. SamuelFeesy says:

    nwux viagra pills pzkg pglr

  150. SamuelFeesy says:

    recf non prescription viagra lltk nsuy

  151. SamuelFeesy says:

    pxmp is viagra over the counter asoq fikk

Leave a Reply