Tea Party Dogma

There’s something that fundamentally bugs me when when I listen to Tea Party folk. Partly it’s the whole “squishiness” of the movement. Disaffected moderates stand next to white supremacists in an organization whose only consistent message seems to be “anger”.  At another level, though, there’s a theme I’ve heard coming from TP folk that strikes a dissonant chord in my brain. What bugs me is their complaint that the US government (mostly via the new healthcare bill) is exceeding its constitutional bounds. They advocate a return to minimalist government as described in the US Constitution.

So what is bothersome about this? Well, I have a visceral reaction to the notion that a small set of fixed rules, written in a flawed language, can possibly capture everything which its author(s) intended. I believe that one of the structural advantages of Christianity over Islam is that the Bible is understood to have been written by imperfect humans whereas the Qur’an is supposed to be the literal transcription of Allah’s words to Muhammed. The former approach leaves us a lot of wiggle room. When Corinthians says, “Let the women keep silent in the churches; for they are not permitted to speak…” and, “And if they desire to learn anything, let them ask their own husbands at home; for it is improper for a woman to speak in church.” Christians (well, many of them) treat this in a historical context and don’t insist that it applies today. When reading surah 2:228 with regard to the rights of women how are we to interpret Allah’s words that “the men have a degree over them”? Does that still apply today? Fuzziness and being open to interpretation can be a good thing.

So, who gets to interpret the US Constitution? Can’t Obama simply say “the commerce clause is the basis for the healthcare bill”? How about Congress? The answer, of course is “no” in both cases. The Supreme Court gets to decide what’s constitutional. Right?

Well, right away we have a problem. Nowhere in the Constitution does it describe the process of judicial review. Let me state this another way, the Constitution does not subject laws to a constitutional test.  And yet, judicial review is an accepted part of our political process. Congress makes the laws, the Executive branch enforces them and the Judicial branch subjects them to constitutional review. How did this come to be?

Well, if you read the Federalist Papers and some history books, you learn that many of the initial 13 states practiced judicial review and that many of the founding fathers were in favor of it (not all, some were against). Finally, in 1803 (Marbury v. Madison), the Supreme Court struck down a law, declaring it unconstitutional and formally established the concept of judicial review in the US.

Understand, then, why the Tea Party logic is problematic. It declares the US Constitution to be the basis for deciding what powers are vested to the Federal Government, but that document alone does not subject federal laws to constitutional review. Only a broader reading of the Constitution and an 1803 opinion of the Supreme Court require laws to comply with the guidelines of the Constitution.

Once we get past that knothole, the Tea Party folk run into another problem. The Supreme Court, the ultimate arbiter of constitutionality, has repeatedly interpreted the commerce clause in a very broad fashion allowing the Federal government to greatly expand its powers. In 1964, the commerce clause was used to justify the Civil Rights act. More recently, the commerce clause justified the preeminence of federal drug laws over state laws (even when drugs never cross state lines).

Will the TP folk stop complaning about the healthcare bill if, ultimately, the Supreme Court rules it constitutional? I bet not. They would probably complain about activist judges on the Court and claim that they’d made a bad decision.

Sigh. You can’t have it both ways. If you’re going to base your arguments on the US Constitution, you can’t then complain if your interpretation of the Constitution is judged to be wrong. Once the Supremes have decided against you, you are simply wrong. The Constitution doesn’t subject the opinion of the Supreme Court to a popular vote. You can disagree with them all you want, but as far as the Constitution is concerned, you are wrong.

By the way, as a point of semantic clarification, conservative Supreme Court behavior is to respect precendence. Since the Supreme Court has previously interpreted the commerce clause in a broad way, it would be considered judicially liberal to reject precedent and to now consider it narrowly. So what the TP folk are really asking for is for the court to behave in an activist fashion in order to re-interpret the commerce clause.

Hey, you know what else is not in the US Constitution? The fillibuster. So when the TP folk complain about the process that was used to pass healthcare legislation, understand that the process would not have been necessary if the Senate had followed the process set out in the Constitution and allowed a simple up-and-down vote. What they’re really complaining about is that the Democrats used deplorable tactics to overcome the deplorable tactics employed by the opposition.

So, I get it: the Tea Party folk are angry. Bank bailouts, deficit spending, terrorism, etc. – plenty of stuff to be scared and angry about. But to hide behind the Constitution? Please.

172 Responses to “Tea Party Dogma”

  1. Hi there! 🙂 My name is Victoria, I’m a student studying Theatre from
    Steegen, Austria. http://aaa-rehab.com

  2. StephenPaply says:

    100mg viagra buy viagra online viagra walmart

  3. Mauricefek says:

    discount viagra viagra for sale viagra online usa

  4. JamesTug says:

    $200 cialis coupon order cialis generic cialis pills

  5. JeremyDeelp says:

    average price cialis cialis online high blood pressure and cialis

  6. Traviscit says:

    online doctor prescription for viagra viagra without a doctor prescription no prescription viagra

  7. EdwardGepay says:

    viagra doses 200 mg viagra roman viagra

  8. JaredSox says:

    buy real viagra online viagra online doctor prescription for viagra

  9. EddieChaix says:

    best male ed pills ed meds online without doctor prescription shots for ed

  10. Samuelfut says:

    men with ed ed pills comparison injections for ed

  11. ThomasBlelt says:

    homeopathic remedies for ed ed prescription drugs online drugstore

  12. JamesfEr says:

    viagra walmart cheap viagra best over the counter viagra

  13. RogerLof says:

    viagra from canada buy viagra online non prescription viagra
    best ed medicine

  14. KennethEpite says:

    viagra amazon cheap ed pills buy viagra online usa
    shots for ed

  15. RogerLof says:

    viagra price buy viagra how much is viagra
    best ed medications

  16. JamesfEr says:

    how much does viagra cost buy ed pills online where to buy viagra

  17. KennethEpite says:

    how much does viagra cost buy generic drugs where can i buy viagra
    mexican pharmacy without prescription

  18. RogerLof says:

    viagra from canada viagra buy viagra online cheap
    ed medications comparison

  19. RogerLof says:

    viagra cost per pill cheap ed pills viagra pill
    best ed supplements

  20. Ernestsmady says:

    prescription drugs without prior prescription generic ed pills ed help

  21. DouglasNix says:

    best ed pills non prescription ED Pills Without Doctor Prescription ed for men

  22. Ernestsmady says:

    medicines for ed Cheap Erection Pills errection problem cure

  23. DouglasNix says:

    male enhancement products ED Pills generic ed pills

  24. Dannyhof says:

    cialis without doctor prescription cialis online how long does 20mg cialis keep in system

  25. ThomasDix says:

    new erectile dysfunction treatment best online canadian pharmacy erectile dysfunction treatment
    ed drugs

  26. Brucedorgo says:

    prices of viagra at walmart ed pills online pharmacy ed natural treatment
    ed men

  27. RobertBurry says:

    pills erectile dysfunction https://canadaedwp.com/ best treatment for ed

  28. ThomasDix says:

    best canadian pharmacy online ed drugs online from canada erectional dysfunction
    herbal remedies for ed

  29. Brucedorgo says:

    erectile dysfunction drug best canadian online pharmacy how to cure ed naturally
    buy drug online

  30. Brucedorgo says:

    best natural ed treatment best online canadian pharmacy erection pills online
    male dysfunction treatment

  31. RobertBurry says:

    treatments for ed https://canadaedwp.com/ home remedies for ed

  32. MichealJab says:

    https://ventolin100mcg.com/ can i buy ventolin online mexico

  33. ThomasHuh says:

    zantac carcinogen zantac generic

  34. MichealJab says:

    https://zithromaxgeneric500.com/ can i buy zithromax over the counter

  35. ThomasHuh says:

    ventolin otc australia generic ventolin price

  36. WilliamBlide says:

    sildenafil pharmacy sildenafil for sale

  37. RobertMum says:

    tadalafil canada buy tadalafil

  38. Williamwat says:

    tadalafil online buy tadalafil

  39. WilliamBlide says:

    tadalafil canada tadalafil for sale

  40. Williamwat says:

    buy sildenafil sildenafil online

  41. RobertMum says:

    buy tadalafil tadalafil pharmacy

  42. Williamwat says:

    sildenafil pharmacy sildenafil generic

  43. RobertMum says:

    payday loans no credit check speedy cash payday loans online

  44. RobertPrina says:

    sildenafil pharmacy sildenafil

  45. CalebNaf says:

    cash advance speedy cash payday loans online

  46. RobertPrina says:

    cheapest sildenafil sildenafil

  47. JoshuaAsype says:

    buy sildenafil https://sildgeneric100.com/ cheapest sildenafil

  48. Douglaspar says:

    medication online https://sildenafilxxl.com/ buy real viagra online

  49. EdwardObedy says:

    medication for ed https://sildenafilxxl.com/ buy real viagra online

  50. EdwardObedy says:

    ed pills comparison https://sildenafilxxl.com/ viagra cialis

  51. Briandicle says:

    new treatments for ed canada drugs online prescription drugs online without

  52. AngeloVes says:

    erectile dysfunction remedies canadian online pharmacy mens ed

  53. Briandicle says:

    does viagra or cialis help with pe cialis daily canadian viagra cialis

  54. AngeloVes says:

    price of viagra viagra where to buy viagra online

  55. Briandicle says:

    real viagra without a doctor prescription canada online pharmacy cheap drugs online

  56. AngeloVes says:

    viagra vs cialis vs levitra cialis for sale how to take cialis

  57. Briandicle says:

    cheap medications online canada drugs online online drugs

  58. AngeloVes says:

    ed supplements buy Zithromax best cure for ed

  59. Philipignof says:

    ed medicines: viagra without a prescription natural cures for ed

  60. GregoryNet says:

    buy prescription drugs without doctor: erectile dysfunction treatment aspirin and ed

  61. Philipignof says:

    pain meds without written prescription: best drugs for ed medication drugs

  62. GregoryNet says:

    drug prices: buy prescription drugs from india erectile dysfunction remedies

  63. GregoryNet says:

    ways to treat erectile dysfunction: canadian drugstore online cheapest ed pills

  64. GregoryNet says:

    medication drugs: best ed pill ed treatment

  65. GregoryNet says:

    ed medications online: cheap ed pills treatment of ed

  66. GregoryNet says:

    best ed pill: best canadian pharmacy online buy medication online

  67. Masonnom says:

    viagra doses 200 mg viagra without a doctor prescription canada over the counter viagra cvs

  68. DanielNub says:

    male enhancement pills canadian pharmacy online best medication for ed

  69. DanielNub says:

    best ed pills that work approved canadian pharmacies online carprofen without vet prescription

  70. DanielNub says:

    best natural cure for ed approved canadian pharmacies online male dysfunction treatment

  71. Masonnom says:

    cialis before and after viagra or cialis cialis prices

  72. DanielNub says:

    interactions for cialis real cialis without a doctor’s prescription the effects of cialis on women

  73. Masonnom says:

    viagra doses 200 mg is viagra over the counter online viagra prescription

  74. DanielNub says:

    zithromax over the counter uk how much is zithromax 250 mg can you buy zithromax over the counter in mexico

  75. Williegof says:

    online viagra prescription https://genericvgr100.online viagra cialis

  76. Williegof says:

    viagra without a doctor prescription https://genericvgr100.online buy real viagra online

  77. Williegof says:

    viagra cost https://genericvgr100.com viagra online canada

  78. WilfredIntep says:

    ed help pharmacy in canada ontario certified canadian online pharmacies

  79. Michaelgot says:

    causes for ed ed drugs generic best ed drugs

  80. WilfredIntep says:

    cenmox 250 cheap Amoxil sexual dysfunction in men

  81. Michaelgot says:

    psychological ed treatment canadian pharmacy cialis online pharmacies without an rx

  82. WilfredIntep says:

    levitra without a doctor prescription best erectile dysfunction medication ed meds rx

  83. Michaelgot says:

    best ed supplements buy Plaquenil buy Valtrex online

  84. WilfredIntep says:

    best medicine for ed canadian healthcare pharmacy canadian pills online

  85. Michaelgot says:

    ed pills for sale ed meds online buy erectile dysfunction pills online

  86. Michaelgot says:

    best online pharmacy reputable mail order pharmacies canada reputable mail order pharmacies canada

  87. WilfredIntep says:

    buy Cenmox Amoxil buy prescription drugs online legally

  88. HaroldJaips says:

    pumps for ed pharmacy online buying pills online

  89. Charlesapeme says:

    how to cure ed natural drugs for ed treatment of ed

  90. HaroldJaips says:

    anti fungal pills without prescription lipitor lipitor 10 mg tablet

  91. Charlesapeme says:

    erectile dysfunction medicines ed pills that work quickly ed cures that actually work

  92. HaroldJaips says:

    levitra without a doctor prescription ed pills that work quickly viagra without doctor prescription

  93. Charlesapeme says:

    ed vacuum pump ed problems treatment erectile dysfunction

  94. HaroldJaips says:

    cure ed canada online pharmacy canadian pharmacies shipping to usa

  95. Charlesapeme says:

    natural ed medications atorvastatin lipitor cheap lipitor generic

  96. HaroldJaips says:

    viagra walmart viagra online canadian pharmacy viagra walgreens

  97. HaroldJaips says:

    natural drugs for ed over the counter ed drugs erectional dysfunction

  98. hey says:

    Taxi moto line
    128 Rue la Boétie
    75008 Paris
    +33 6 51 612 712  

    Taxi moto paris

    Hi there just wanted to give you a quick heads
    up. The words in your content seem to be running off the screen in Internet
    explorer. I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I figured I’d post to let you know.

    The style and design look great though! Hope you get the problem resolved soon. Thanks

  99. Independance Immobilière – Agence Dakar Sénégal
    Av. Fadiga, Immeuble Lahad Mbacké
    BP 2975 Dakar
    +221 33 823 39 30

    Agence Immobilière Dakar

    After looking at a number of the articles on your site,
    I truly like your technique of writing a blog.
    I added it to my bookmark website list and will
    be checking back in the near future. Please check out my web site too and let me know
    your opinion.

  100. M.E.C Mon Electricien Catalan
    44 Rue Henry de Turenne
    66100 Perpignan
    0651212596

    Electricien Perpignan

    It is appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it’s
    time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I
    wish to suggest you few interesting things or tips.
    Maybe you can write next articles referring to this article.
    I wish to read even more things about it!

  101. WilliamPam says:

    viagra cheap https://cheapvgr100.online/ cbgmgerp

  102. WilliamPam says:

    owyuewog how much viagra should i take the first time? non prescription viagra

  103. WilliamPam says:

    hyqohiec buy cheap viagra price of viagra

  104. IsaacHuche says:

    viagra online usa https://cheapvgr100.com/ xeampcxj

  105. Johnnysweap says:

    benadryl best price 10.00 allegra coupon 5.00 allegra coupon

  106. RobertOdoks says:

    yasmin estrogen yasmin discount yasmin medicine price

  107. Johnnysweap says:

    where to buy amoxicillin 500mg zithromax z-pak zithromax over the counter

  108. RobertOdoks says:

    levlen canada shatavari buy levlen

  109. RobertOdoks says:

    buy zithromax buy amoxil over the counter amoxicillin canada

  110. Johnnysweap says:

    zithromax capsules price medicine amoxicillin 500mg amoxicillin price canada

  111. RobertOdoks says:

    valtrex purchase online purchase zovirax cream valtrex over the counter canada

  112. Johnnysweap says:

    doxycycline pills amoxicillin online canada antibiotic toxicity symptoms

  113. RobertOdoks says:

    yasmin parvaneh yasmin generics buy shatavari

  114. RobertOdoks says:

    aciclovir tablets 500 mg acyclovir without prescription acyclovir 800

  115. Johnnysweap says:

    how much is valtrex generic can you buy valtrex over the counter in canada how to order valtrex

  116. RobertOdoks says:

    doxycycline 200 mg canadian pharmacy amoxicillin buy generic zithromax no prescription

  117. Johnnysweap says:

    allegra 180 mg price benadryl generic brand 3 benadryl tablets

  118. RobertOdoks says:

    diverticulitis antibiotic treatment bactrim sulfamethoxazole amoxicillin buy canada

  119. RobertOdoks says:

    clomid no prescription serophene 50 mg price yasmin rizvi

  120. Jamesarify says:

    viagra walmart http://viagrastm.com/ order viagra online

  121. Richardalups says:

    does viagra or cialis help with pe http://cialisirt.com/ cialis coupon code epyrohvy

  122. Richardalups says:

    over the counter viagra cvs http://viagrastm.com/ viagra from canada tyywihtl

  123. Jamesarify says:

    how often to take 10mg cialis http://cialisirt.com/ cost of cialis

  124. Jamesarify says:

    cialis patent expiration http://cialisirt.com/ nose congested when taking cialis

  125. GeorgeCip says:

    pain meds online without doctor prescription https://canadianpharmacyvikky.com top ed drugs

  126. Jessefap says:

    best ed pills non prescription https://canadianpharmacyvikky.com ed treatments that really work

  127. GeorgeCip says:

    ed meds online https://canadianpharmacyvikky.com viagra without doctor prescription amazon

  128. JasonLot says:

    amoxicillin buy canada amoxicillin 500mg capsules antibiotic

  129. JasonLot says:

  130. JasonLot says:

    ventolin 50 mg buy ventolin over the counter australia

  131. JasonLot says:

    medicine amoxicillin 500mg amoxicillin 500 mg price

  132. I’m commenting to let you be aware of of the amazing discovery my child developed browsing the blog. She came to find a good number of details, including how it is like to have a great coaching character to get a number of people clearly completely grasp a number of advanced issues. You actually did more than her desires. I appreciate you for churning out such beneficial, dependable, edifying and cool guidance on that topic to Emily.

  133. JasonLot says:

    amoxicillin discount amoxicillin 500 tablet

  134. tadalafil says:

    I am just writing to make you understand what a perfect experience my wife’s princess obtained using your webblog. She noticed some things, which included what it is like to possess an excellent teaching spirit to make others with no trouble learn about specific specialized things. You undoubtedly surpassed readers’ expected results. Thanks for providing those priceless, trusted, informative as well as unique tips on your topic to Mary.

  135. JasonLot says:

    zantac generic zantac prices

  136. JasonLot says:

    male dysfunction pills best online drugstore

  137. JasonLot says:

    drugs and medications ed pills that work quickly

  138. Khthsmat says:

    e d canadian pharmacy online erectile dysfunction medications

  139. paxil says:

    I’m just commenting to let you be aware of of the fabulous discovery my cousin’s daughter experienced going through your site. She even learned lots of issues, most notably how it is like to have a very effective giving mindset to have many others just gain knowledge of chosen grueling matters. You really did more than our desires. Many thanks for distributing the important, healthy, educational and as well as easy thoughts on the topic to Gloria.

  140. I am only writing to make you understand what a remarkable experience our princess undergone viewing your webblog. She picked up such a lot of things, with the inclusion of what it is like to possess an ideal teaching spirit to make the mediocre ones without difficulty fully grasp a variety of complicated matters. You actually did more than my desires. I appreciate you for delivering such great, dependable, edifying and also cool guidance on that topic to Evelyn.

  141. Jlloirore says:

    erectile dysfunction drug pharmacies near me rx

  142. Fwsxapeno says:

    rx plus pharmacy canadian pharmacies canadian drug pharmacy

  143. JasonLot says:

  144. Lokuapeno says:

    canadian pharcharmy erection pills the pharmacy

  145. A lot of thanks for each of your hard work on this web page. Kim really likes going through investigation and it’s really easy to understand why. Many of us know all of the dynamic method you make powerful strategies on this web blog and as well as improve participation from people on that issue so our girl is in fact learning a lot of things. Have fun with the remaining portion of the new year. You are conducting a really good job.

  146. FgvdExork says:

    erectile dysfunction treatment best drugstore eyeshadow mail order pharmacy

  147. MichaelBrind says:

    muse for ed https://canadarx24.com/ cheap erectile dysfunction

  148. Aqwsapeno says:

    ed board of pharmacy cheap erectile dysfunction pills online

  149. MichaelBrind says:

    ed pills that really work https://canadarx24.com/ drug medication

  150. Davidchupt says:

    ed medications https://canadarx24.com/ male enhancement

  151. NllpExork says:

    best drugstore face wash http://pharmacy-onlineasxs.com/ best drugstore bronzer

  152. Jtmfapeno says:

    ed medication 24 hr pharmacy pharmacy open near me

  153. Davidchupt says:

    ed tablets https://canadarx24.com/ real viagra without a doctor prescription

  154. Davidchupt says:

    canadian drug https://canadarx24.com/ ed aids

  155. Jasongof says:

    natural ed jpklsmee levitra generic cheap erectile dysfunction pills online

  156. Jasongof says:

    viagra doses 200 mg pnpeavjj buy viagra online viagra without a prescription

  157. Daviddilky says:

    cialis patent expiration xdpcbhnu http://edcheapgeneric.online/ viagra vs cialis vs levitra

  158. Jasongof says:

    low cost cialis cialis generic urzudcya fda warning list cialis

  159. Thanks for the tips about credit repair on this blog. Things i would advice people would be to give up the actual mentality that they’ll buy right now and pay out later. Like a society all of us tend to do that for many things. This includes holidays, furniture, as well as items we would like. However, you have to separate your own wants from all the needs. When you are working to improve your credit rating score make some sacrifices. For example you are able to shop online to save money or you can turn to second hand shops instead of costly department stores with regard to clothing.

  160. Jasongof says:

    erectial dysfunction fwsgyedl levitra generic cheap pills online

  161. Daviddilky says:

    causes for ed http://canadarx24.online/ anti fungal pills without prescription cchidnir

  162. btc clicks says:

    It’s very trouble-free to find out any topic on net as compared to books, as I
    found this paragraph at this web site.

  163. Jasongof says:

    male erectile dysfunction bdqydrei order levitra ed medicine online

  164. Robertonelf says:

    urtv viagra no prescription http://dietkannur.org bxdc dsed

  165. Geraldcus says:

    meds online without doctor prescription buy viagra very cheap

Leave a Reply